Warehouse shelving stacked with cardboard boxes, the kind of 3PL inventory that can create state tax nexus

Inventory at a U.S. Warehouse? 3PL Inventory Nexus for Foreign-Owned Sellers

Storing goods at a U.S. warehouse can create 3PL inventory nexus for state income tax, even when Amazon or TikTok Shop already collects your sales tax. A third-party logistics (3PL) provider is a company that stores, packs, and ships products for sellers. This article explains why inventory changes the analysis, which federal rules still apply, and what foreign-owned sellers should review before peak season.

Sales tax collection does not settle income tax

Nexus is the connection with a state that lets it tax a business. Sales tax nexus and income tax nexus are separate questions with separate rules.

The Supreme Court allowed states to require sales tax collection based on economic activity alone in South Dakota v. Wayfair, Inc., decided June 21, 2018. States then adopted marketplace facilitator laws. These laws require platforms such as Amazon to collect and remit sales tax on third-party sales, according to the Streamlined Sales Tax Governing Board.

Marketplace collection covers sales tax only. It does not file a corporate income tax return or a franchise tax report for the seller.

How 3PL inventory nexus works

A federal law limits state income taxes on out-of-state sellers. Public Law 86-272, codified at 15 U.S.C. Section 381, bars a state from imposing a net income tax when the seller’s only in-state activity is soliciting orders for tangible goods. The orders must be approved outside the state and filled by shipment from outside the state.

Inventory stored inside the state does not fit that description. The goods ship from a point inside the state, not outside it.

The Multistate Tax Commission (MTC) is an agency of member states that publishes uniform guidance. Its Statement of Information on Public Law 86-272, revised August 4, 2021, lists unprotected activities. The list includes maintaining a warehouse in the state and keeping a stock of goods other than samples. The statement also lists consigning goods to another person, including an independent contractor, for sale.

Public Law 86-272 also applies only to net income taxes. It does not protect a seller from gross receipts taxes or sales tax.

State examples: California and Texas

California uses bright-line “doing business” tests. Under the California Franchise Tax Board thresholds, a taxpayer is doing business for 2025 if California sales exceed $757,070 or California property exceeds $75,707. Property includes inventory. The 2024 thresholds were $735,019 for sales and $73,502 for property.

Texas imposes a franchise tax rather than a net income tax, so Public Law 86-272 does not apply. Under 34 Texas Administrative Code Section 3.586, having inventory in Texas is a physical presence that creates nexus. The same rule creates economic nexus for a foreign entity with $500,000 or more in Texas gross receipts. The Texas Comptroller lists a no-tax-due threshold of $2,650,000 for 2026 and 2027 reports. A business below that threshold may still need to file information reports.

Courts do not always agree

Some sellers do not choose where a marketplace stores their goods. Pennsylvania’s Commonwealth Court addressed that fact in Online Merchants Guild v. Hassell, decided September 9, 2022.

The court held that sellers whose only Pennsylvania contact was Amazon-stored inventory lacked the minimum contacts needed for sales tax and personal income tax. The court stressed that Amazon alone decided where the goods went. The case did not address corporate net income tax. Results in other states and for other taxes may differ.

A hypothetical example

Assume a U.K. company owns 100 percent of a Delaware corporation. The corporation sells home goods to U.S. customers through a marketplace. Its inventory sits in fulfillment centers in California and Texas.

The marketplace collects sales tax in both states. The corporation may still need a California franchise tax return if its California sales or property pass the 2025 thresholds. It may also need a Texas franchise tax report because it holds inventory in Texas.

Federal filings still apply

State filings sit on top of federal obligations. A U.S. corporation that is at least 25 percent foreign-owned must file Form 5472 with its Form 1120. A U.S. single-member LLC owned by one foreign person is treated as a corporation for this purpose under Treasury Regulation Section 1.6038A-1(c)(1). That LLC files a pro forma Form 1120 with Form 5472 attached.

The penalty for failing to file Form 5472 is $25,000 under IRC Section 6038A(d). Our earlier posts on foreign owned LLC tax classification and Form 5472 penalties cover these rules in more detail.

Foreign companies without a U.S. entity

Some sellers ship from a foreign parent company with no U.S. subsidiary. A tax treaty may shield that company from federal tax on business profits unless it has a permanent establishment in the United States. A permanent establishment is a fixed place of business that allows the other country to tax business profits.

Article 5(4) of the 2016 U.S. Model Income Tax Convention excludes facilities used solely for storage, display, or delivery of the company’s goods. Each actual treaty must be checked, because terms vary by country.

A foreign corporation that concludes it owes no U.S. tax may still file a protective Form 1120-F. Under Treasury Regulation Section 1.882-4(a)(3), a late return can cost the corporation its deductions and credits. A timely protective return preserves them.

Treaties generally do not bind the states. Treasury’s 1996 Model Technical Explanation states that U.S. state and local taxes are not covered, except under the nondiscrimination article. A company with no federal permanent establishment can still owe state income or franchise tax.

Steps to take before peak season

  1. List every state where your 3PL or marketplace stores your goods. Request inventory location reports by month.
  2. Compare sales, property, and payroll in each state to its nexus thresholds.
  3. Check whether each state imposes a net income tax, a franchise tax, or a gross receipts tax.
  4. Register with each state where nexus exists, and calendar the first return due date.
  5. Confirm that federal Forms 1120, 5472, or 1120-F are on schedule.

If a state notice arrives first, our guide to the first 30 days after a state tax notice explains how to respond. Our post on state taxes for remote organizations covers payroll-based nexus.

How Acully Tax can help

Acully Tax prepares Form 1120, Form 1120-F, and Form 5472 for foreign-owned businesses. Our tax consultation service can map your inventory locations to state filing requirements. Contact Acully Tax to review your 3PL footprint before your next return is due.

Sources

This article is for general information only and is not tax or legal advice. Consult a qualified tax professional about your situation.

2 responses to “Inventory at a U.S. Warehouse? 3PL Inventory Nexus for Foreign-Owned Sellers”

  1. […] obligation. Inventory stored in a state can also create income or franchise tax nexus. Our post on 3PL inventory nexus covers that issue. If a state has already sent a letter, our guide to the first 30 days after a […]

  2. […] goods with a U.S. logistics provider should review that contract with a tax adviser. Our post on 3PL inventory nexus covers the separate state sales tax […]

Leave a Reply

Spam-free subscription, we guarantee. This is just a friendly ping when new content is out.

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨