A sales tax voluntary disclosure can limit how many past years a state reviews and waive most penalties for an online seller that never registered. This article explains how sellers fall behind in several states, how to measure the exposure, and when a voluntary disclosure agreement (VDA) is a better first step than registering directly. A VDA is a written agreement in which a business reports past tax it owes in exchange for a limited lookback and penalty relief.
How online sellers fall behind
Nexus is the connection with a state that lets it require a business to collect its tax. Before 2018, sales tax nexus generally required a physical presence. The U.S. Supreme Court changed that in South Dakota v. Wayfair, Inc., decided June 21, 2018. The South Dakota law upheld in that case applied to sellers with more than $100,000 of sales or 200 or more separate transactions in the state each year.
Each state now sets its own economic nexus threshold. The figures below come from each state’s revenue agency:
- California: sales of tangible personal property into the state exceeding $500,000 in the current or preceding calendar year, according to the CDTFA.
- Texas: total Texas revenue of $500,000 or more in the preceding 12 calendar months, according to the Texas Comptroller.
- New York: more than $500,000 in receipts and more than 100 sales in the preceding four sales tax quarters, according to the New York Department of Taxation and Finance.
- Florida: taxable remote sales exceeding $100,000 in the previous calendar year, according to Florida TIP 21A01-03.
- Illinois: $100,000 or more in gross receipts, with no transaction count test starting January 1, 2026, according to Illinois Bulletin FY 2026-12.
A seller can cross several of these thresholds in one strong year without noticing. Growth through a website, a marketplace, and wholesale accounts adds up quickly.
Step 1: measure exposure state by state
Start with sales by ship-to state for each year since 2018. Separate direct sales from marketplace sales. Then compare each year to that state’s threshold.
Marketplace sales often count toward the seller’s own threshold, even when the marketplace collects the tax. The Texas Comptroller’s marketplace FAQ says sellers “must include all sales in the safe harbor calculation, including marketplace sales.” Its example adds $300,000 of website sales to $300,000 of marketplace sales, which exceeds $500,000. New York also counts marketplace sales.
For each state over the threshold, estimate the uncollected tax by year. Exempt sales, resale sales, and marketplace-collected sales reduce the amount owed. Clean books make this step faster. Our year-end bookkeeping cleanup guide lists the reconciliations to finish first.
Step 2: register directly or use a sales tax voluntary disclosure
Registering directly fixes future periods. It does not limit the past. A state can assess every open period back to the date nexus began, plus penalties and interest.
A VDA limits the lookback. California’s out-of-state voluntary disclosure program “limits the time CDTFA can assess overdue use tax to three years,” compared with eight years otherwise, according to the CDTFA. Revenue and Taxation Code section 6487.05 sets that three-year limit.
Texas uses a four-year lookback. Under Texas Publication 96-576, the Comptroller limits its review to reports due four years from the date the business first makes contact. Texas also offers relief from penalties and, in most cases, from interest.
Who qualifies
Eligibility usually ends once the state contacts you. Texas excludes a business “previously contacted by the Comptroller, either verbally or in writing,” or one that has received an audit notice. California requires that the seller never registered and was not previously contacted by the CDTFA.
This is why order matters. Registering in a state before applying for a VDA can disqualify the seller from that state’s program.
The multistate program
The Multistate Tax Commission (MTC) runs a Multistate Voluntary Disclosure Program through its National Nexus Program. One application can cover several participating states. Until an agreement is signed, the seller “is known to that state only by its voluntary disclosure Case Number.”
The MTC FAQ states that “each state determines its own lookback period.” Penalties are waived for the lookback period, but interest is generally still due. Prior contact on a tax type, including a filed return or a state inquiry, disqualifies the seller for that tax.
Tax you collected but did not remit
The limited lookback does not cover tax a seller collected from customers and kept. The MTC FAQ states that “sales/use tax collected from others must be remitted in its entirety.” Texas states there is “no limit on the lookback period for taxes collected and not remitted.”
Owners and officers can also be personally liable. Under California Revenue and Taxation Code section 6829, a responsible person who willfully fails to pay can be held liable when a corporation or LLC terminates, dissolves, or is abandoned.
Step 3: file the catch-up returns
Once a VDA is signed, the work follows a set order:
- Register for a permit in the state, as the agreement requires.
- File the returns or the schedule of liability for each lookback period.
- Pay the tax and any interest by the agreement deadline.
- Turn on collection at checkout for that state going forward.
- Calendar each state’s filing frequency and due dates.
Sales tax collection is only one state obligation. Inventory stored in a state can also create income or franchise tax nexus. Our post on 3PL inventory nexus covers that issue. If a state has already sent a letter, our guide to the first 30 days after a state tax notice explains the next steps.
A note on Streamlined Sales Tax amnesty
The Streamlined Sales Tax (SST) program once offered amnesty to sellers that registered through its central system. The SST Governing Board now states that “Tennessee is the only state offering amnesty at this time.” Most sellers should plan on state VDAs instead.
Work with Acully Tax
Acully Tax helps online sellers measure multistate exposure, compare VDAs with direct registration, and resolve past noncompliance. Our compliance guidance and noncompliance resolution services, together with monthly bookkeeping, keep each state current after the catch-up. Contact Acully Tax to book a consultation.
Sources
- U.S. Supreme Court, Docket No. 17-494, South Dakota v. Wayfair, Inc.
- CDTFA, Out-of-State Retailers: Registration
- Texas Comptroller, Remote Sellers
- Texas Comptroller, Remote Sellers and Marketplace FAQ
- New York Department of Taxation and Finance, Sales Tax Nexus
- Florida Department of Revenue, TIP 21A01-03
- Illinois Department of Revenue, Bulletin FY 2026-12
- CDTFA, Out-of-State Voluntary Disclosure Program
- California Revenue and Taxation Code section 6487.05
- Texas Comptroller, Publication 96-576, Voluntary Disclosure Agreement
- Multistate Tax Commission, Multistate Voluntary Disclosure Program
- Multistate Tax Commission, National Nexus Program FAQ
- CDTFA-162-E, Personal Liability (R&TC section 6829)
- Streamlined Sales Tax Governing Board, Amnesty
This article is for general information only and is not tax or legal advice. Consult a qualified tax professional about your situation.


Leave a Reply