Acully Opinion: U.S. Source Income (ECTI) revisited again and again.

It seems like not a day goes by when I am talking to a founder or owner who has set up a U.S. entity and thinks that because he is outside the U.S. or his customers are outside the U.S. he has no tax liability. When I ask where this advice is coming from I am finding that it comes from blogs, posting on the web or even certain websites devoted to entity formation. One common denominator is that you will not find a major U.S. CPA or law firm on the other end of this sort of advice.

Let’s quickly revisit the idea of U.S. Source Income and Effectively Connected Taxable Income (ECTI). First of all why is this important? The simple answer is that if a LLC or Corporation is doing business in the U.S. and has ECTI, then it must file tax returns and pay tax in the U.S.

What is ECTI? The IRS who administers the tax laws in the U.S. unfortunately has left this definition sufficiently vague. Lets not get into the technical side of things and look at what determines ECTI. Common explanations I hear from foreign business owners is that I have no property, payroll or management in the U.S. and most of my clients are outside the U.S. and I am outside the U.S. Property, payroll or management would certainly create a filing obligation in the U.S. but these are not all the determining factors.

When I ask a founder if they have a U.S. bank account, most times, they proudly say yes. I ask him or her if they signed up for the bank as a U.S. company they also say yes. Then I ask if they are contracting and selling their products or services as a U.S. company I usually get a somewhat puzzled answer saying yes and asking ” why else would I have formed a company in the U.S.” Given that they have told the bank and their customers they are a U.S. entity they are now following the incorrect advice to tell the IRS that they are not subject to the rules that every other entity would need to follow in reporting income. I can go on with other examples but the point is that ECTI is an all encompassing term that describes when income is U.S. source and requires reporting and taxation.

Foreign founders and owners. . . please disregard the notion of property, payroll and location of the owner and customers and look at the realities of why you are forming a business here. The U.S. is certainly not known to be a tax haven and should not be treated as such. Many owners not only do not file in the U.S. but think this exemption applies to filing and paying a tax in their home countries. In other words a worldwide exemption on taxation which could not be further from reality.

One last thing, is that if you get advice and hear the words “Permanent Establishment” and the lack thereof exempts you from filing returns and paying tax keep in mind that this term comes from Tax Treaties the U.S. has with multiple countries. To get to a treaty you must file a tax return to seek relief from taxation in one of the two countries.

Dispute this opinion. . . please add a comment below.

Leave a Reply

Spam-free subscription, we guarantee. This is just a friendly ping when new content is out.

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨